Is Closing a Credit Card a Bad Idea? The Truth About Your Credit Score

When it comes to managing your finances, few decisions spark as much debate as closing a credit card.

Will it tank your credit score?

Or could it actually help your financial health?

The answer isn’t as straightforward as you might think.

Your credit score is a delicate ecosystem, and every move you make—whether opening, closing, or maintaining an account—can have ripple effects.

Let’s dive into the nuances of closing a credit card and uncover the truth about how it impacts your creditworthiness.

Moreover, understanding your credit score is crucial for making informed financial decisions.

It’s not just a number; it reflects your borrowing behavior and financial responsibility.

Understanding the Role of Credit Utilization

One of the most critical factors in your credit score is your credit utilization ratio—the amount of credit you’re using compared to your total available credit.

Closing a credit card reduces your available credit, which can increase your utilization ratio.

For example, if you have a $10,000 credit limit across two cards and close one with a $5,000 limit, your available credit drops to $5,000.

If you’re carrying a $2,000 balance, your utilization jumps from 20% to 40%, potentially hurting your score.

+ What Is a Secured Credit Card, and How Does It Work?

Table 1: Credit Utilization Before and After Closing a Card

As you can see, closing a credit card can significantly alter your financial landscape.

But does that mean you should never close an account?

Not necessarily.

In some cases, reducing your credit limit can help curb overspending habits.

If you find yourself relying too heavily on credit, closing an account may encourage better financial discipline.

The Age of Your Credit History Matters

Another factor to consider is the age of your credit accounts.

Credit scoring models like FICO and VantageScore favor older accounts because they demonstrate a longer history of responsible credit use.

If the card you’re considering closing is one of your oldest, shutting it down could shorten your average account age, potentially lowering your score.

However, if the card is relatively new and you have other older accounts, the impact might be minimal.

For instance, a 2021 study by Experian found that consumers with the highest credit scores (above 800) had an average credit history of 25 years.

If closing a newer card doesn’t drastically reduce your average account age, the effect on your score could be negligible.

Additionally, maintaining older accounts can be beneficial in the long run.

The longer you keep accounts in good standing, the more favorable your credit history appears to lenders.

When Closing a Credit Card Makes Sense

While the potential downsides are real, there are situations where closing a credit card is the right move.

For example:

1. High Annual Fees: If you’re paying hundreds of dollars in annual fees for a card you rarely use, closing it could save you money.

Before doing so, consider calling the issuer to see if they can downgrade you to a no-fee version.

2. Temptation to Overspend: If having multiple cards leads to impulsive spending, reducing the number of accounts can help you regain control of your finances.
3. Divorce or Separation: In cases where joint accounts are involved, closing shared cards can prevent future financial entanglements.

Moreover, if you’re not benefiting from rewards or perks associated with a particular card, it may be more practical to close it.

This can free up mental space and allow you to focus on cards that truly serve your financial goals.

The Myth of the “Perfect” Credit Score

Many people obsess over maintaining a perfect credit score, but the reality is that you don’t need an 850 to qualify for the best rates.

According to FICO, a score of 740 or higher is generally enough to secure favorable terms on loans and credit cards.

If closing a credit card causes a temporary dip in your score, it’s unlikely to have a long-term impact on your financial opportunities—as long as you continue to manage your remaining accounts responsibly.

Additionally, it’s essential to remember that credit scores fluctuate over time.

A single decision, like closing a card, may not define your overall creditworthiness.

Alternatives to Closing a Credit Card

If you’re on the fence about closing a credit card, consider these alternatives:

1. Downgrade to a No-Fee Card: Many issuers allow you to switch to a card with no annual fee, preserving your credit limit and account history.
2. Use It Sparingly: Make a small purchase every few months to keep the account active without accumulating debt.
3. Request a Credit Limit Increase: If you’re worried about utilization, ask for a higher limit on another card to offset the reduction in available credit.

Table 2: Pros and Cons of Closing a Credit Card

Furthermore, keeping your credit accounts open can contribute positively to your credit history.

This can be particularly beneficial when applying for new credit in the future.

The Long-Term Impact on Your Credit Score

While closing a credit card can have immediate effects, its long-term impact depends on how you manage your remaining accounts.

If you continue to make on-time payments, keep your balances low, and maintain a mix of credit types, your score will likely recover over time.

It’s also worth noting that closed accounts in good standing can remain on your credit report for up to 10 years, continuing to contribute to your credit history.

This means the negative effects of closing a card may be less severe than you think.

Additionally, having a diverse credit mix can enhance your score.

This means that even if you close one card, maintaining different types of credit can help keep your score robust.

++ Here’s how to apply for CapitalOne Venture

Final Thoughts: Weighing the Pros and Cons

Deciding whether to close a credit card isn’t a one-size-fits-all decision.

It requires a careful evaluation of your financial goals, spending habits, and credit profile.

While closing a credit card can have some downsides, it’s not inherently a bad idea—especially if it aligns with your broader financial strategy.

Ultimately, your credit score is just one piece of the puzzle.

By focusing on responsible credit management and making informed decisions, you can maintain a healthy financial life—with or without that extra card in your wallet.

Moreover, understanding the nuances of your credit score can empower you to make better financial choices.

By weighing the pros and cons carefully, you can navigate your credit journey with confidence.

By understanding the nuances of closing a credit card, you can make smarter choices that align with your financial goals.

Whether you decide to close an account or keep it open, the key is to stay informed and proactive about your credit health.

This proactive approach will ultimately lead to better financial outcomes in the long run.

Diego 14 de February de 2025